Jump to content
  • 0

Failure of my horizontal mesh


johnfarl

Question

This is the second time i have had a rev where the mesh splits where you bend it for storage. It seems the mesh is more brittle than the dacron and eventually splits where it is sewn to the LE pocket.

What I did for a repair is take a 2 inch long piece of dacron and sewed it over the split which is about 1/2 inch long. Sewed it zigzag along LE pocket and along the sail material hem. Then vertical straight stitch throught the mesh. Hopefully this captures the mesh. I think this will prevent further spliting of the mesh and I also think such a small amount of dacron will not affect the aerodynamics of the kite. This would seem like a logical solution to problem with Revs. The first kite I experience the problem on was REV 2 and the whole top of the mesh split out. I think there is a lot of tensile force on that seam so if there is a small split it will eventually grow big.

Would even seem logical for REV to put dacron strips where you bend the sail for storage. Little extra labor but might fix a weak point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Recommended Posts

  • 0

that sounds like iy would be okay fix for it i just dont know why you didnt call rev ...i know for a fact they have the best customer service around not that ive had many repairs ..but when i did rev was right there ben and lolly and the whole crew there are the greatest when it comes to backing up the product thats just my two cents

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

I had that problem with my '89 Rev I and at the time noticed that the tears in the mesh seemed to occur at the points where the sail was folded -- the location of the splits in the leading edge rods.

Since then, I've been careful to pull the rods out a bit, leaving a wider space between the ends internal to the leading edge, before folding the kite. I've not had the mesh rip on any of my other revs over the last 18 or so years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
I had that problem with my '89 Rev I and at the time noticed that the tears in the mesh seemed to occur at the points where the sail was folded -- the location of the splits in the leading edge rods.

Since then, I've been careful to pull the rods out a bit, leaving a wider space between the ends internal to the leading edge, before folding the kite. I've not had the mesh rip on any of my other revs over the last 18 or so years.

Also roll it up a bit looser.

It doesn't have to be a tight roll in the bag.

Don't wrench it up so much.

Bazzer

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Yes ANT a week point. I am one kite down due the tears in the mesh(same place too). I have changed the way I store my kites.

Like Bazzer, I roll much looser now.

Like jburka, I now pull the rods out a bit, leaving a wider space between the ends.

add to that using that space, I try to fold in a different place on the sail each time.

I also now put the verticals in after the first or second roll so they are not rubbing against the screen.

Who knows perhaps all this helps.

If they never wore out I could never get new ones.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Re-posted from another thread:

Here is a quick 'n' dirty way to repair a rip in the mesh- think of it as a band-aid solution rather than a permanent cure.

post-1987-1206546656_thumb.jpg post-1987-1206546675_thumb.jpg post-1987-1206546691_thumb.jpg

I just run a fairly tight line of zig-zag stitching along the rip, catching the leading edge Dacron on one side and the untorn mesh squares on the other.

My old Vented 1.5 had several tears in its mesh and I repaired them in well under a minute.

Eventually I'll do a proper job and sew a new leading edge and mesh on, but this band-aid keeps the kites going until I get around to replacing it.

I have flown 2 of my older Revs after this repair in winds in excess of 25 knots over the last few months without problems.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

This is a common problem.

During a visit to Rev a few weeks ago, I asked Lolly about these screen failures. She said that the screen is being torn by the edge of the heavy material along the top of the leading edge when the kite is rolled. That makes sense to me, because that is exactly where the screen fails. A horizontal tear at the top, not an vertical tear where the kite is folded.

To prevent this failure, Lolly suggests that after the kite is folded in thirds, place the vertical spars against the screen, at the top next to the heavy material, and make one fold, keeping the entire leeading edge flat with the spars for support, then continue rolling the kite.

Makes sense to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Another thing that helps is ensuring you have some space between the ends of the spars inside the leading edge material...

An inch or so should do it, and lessen the stress at the fold point.

If you're really particular, you could also move the fold point by an inch or so every now and then. ;)

Me, I just roll it clean (not too tight) and bag it... Very few of the screens on my kites have had problems.

But, I also don't crash very much anymore. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Another thing that helps is ensuring you have some space between the ends of the spars inside the leading edge material...

An inch or so should do it, and lessen the stress at the fold point.

If you're really particular, you could also move the fold point by an inch or so every now and then. ;)

Me, I just roll it clean (not too tight) and bag it... Very few of the screens on my kites have had problems.

But, I also don't crash very much anymore. ;)

Another thing I would like to point out. Don't use your packed REV as a walking stick! Otherwise you would push the cracking of the screen even more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Another thing I would like to point out. Don't use your packed REV as a walking stick! Otherwise you would push the cracking of the screen even more.

I've been doing that for so long that when I make new bags I put a layer of kevlar at the bottom so I don't wear a hole in the fabric and lose a spar out of the bottom!

It occurs to me, though, that the kites I'm usually using as a walking stick are custom rev IIs with a 1.5oz ripstop leading edge (and dacron reinforcements at the ends and where the spines meet the LE) so if Lolly's thinking about the sharpness of the dacron LE causing cuts, I wouldn't be nearly as susceptible to that on my IIs (though my 1.5s would...)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Having read this thread, looked at my kites and reflected on a life in sailing I was wondering why nobody rolls their sails along the leading edge as you would any laminate dinghy or yacht sail for storage? .... I pondered it to the point where at 11:45pm I grabbed my rev back took out all 6 (currently) kites and proceeded to repack them this way ... so far my thoughts are....

Con's...

1. Time/convenience ... have to remove leading edge entirely, then roll smoothly entire length

2. Bulk ... resultant pack has greater diameter but is shorter (excl rods)

Pro's...

1. No crease/fatigue points in Mylar or mesh.. longer life

2. If you regularly swap rods/frames between kites its easy to slide rods out from 'roll' without unpacking kite.

Reality...

I have kind of settled on a middle ground.... In the field depending on the breeze I will pack away any nylon sail in the conventional manner ...My Blast 2.4, Ssonic or shockwaves I will try and remove LE then roll around the rods if possible, either way when I get home I take the time to not only do the sand/dirt rinse out but then to repack all sails by rolling this way before returning them to my rev bag ....and obviously there's no point going to all this effort and then strapping up your bag as tight as possible .... I've negotiated a location with 'management' where I am allowed to keep my rev bag loosely rolled and away from marauding children!

Not sure this will make much difference to the life-span of nylon 1.5 or B's but pretty sure any sail with mylar panels will benefit.

Am I mad? .... flame away

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Having read this thread, looked at my kites and reflected on a life in sailing I was wondering why nobody rolls their sails along the leading edge as you would any laminate dinghy or yacht sail for storage? .... I pondered it to the point where at 11:45pm I grabbed my rev back took out all 6 (currently) kites and proceeded to repack them this way ... so far my thoughts are....

Con's...

1. Time/convenience ... have to remove leading edge entirely, then roll smoothly entire length

2. Bulk ... resultant pack has greater diameter but is shorter (excl rods)

Pro's...

1. No crease/fatigue points in Mylar or mesh.. longer life

2. If you regularly swap rods/frames between kites its easy to slide rods out from 'roll' without unpacking kite.

Reality...

I have kind of settled on a middle ground.... In the field depending on the breeze I will pack away any nylon sail in the conventional manner ...My Blast 2.4, Ssonic or shockwaves I will try and remove LE then roll around the rods if possible, either way when I get home I take the time to not only do the sand/dirt rinse out but then to repack all sails by rolling this way before returning them to my rev bag ....and obviously there's no point going to all this effort and then strapping up your bag as tight as possible .... I've negotiated a location with 'management' where I am allowed to keep my rev bag loosely rolled and away from marauding children!

Not sure this will make much difference to the life-span of nylon 1.5 or B's but pretty sure any sail with mylar panels will benefit.

Am I mad? .... flame away

Idea are always interesting to listen to!

Could you roll a REV up in the way you describe and photograph it for us?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Idea are always interesting to listen to!

Could you roll a REV up in the way you describe and photograph it for us?

Your wish is my command (please excuse iPhone camera!)...

Took advantage of 8 knots of breeze and a sunny morning to sneak out of the house at 7am and snatch a quick hour with the 2~4 got back in before anyone was up just in time to cook the pancakes! ... anyway convinced now this is how I will pack my mylar sails .. works for me!

Sunday chores beckon but at least I've had my fix..

post-2056-1208072236_thumb.jpg

post-2056-1208072455_thumb.jpg

post-2056-1208072488_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Your wish is my command (please excuse iPhone camera!)...

Took advantage of 8 knots of breeze and a sunny morning to sneak out of the house at 7am and snatch a quick hour with the 2~4 got back in before anyone was up just in time to cook the pancakes! ... anyway convinced now this is how I will pack my mylar sails .. works for me!

Sunday chores beckon but at least I've had my fix..

Got to check that out with a REV series and see if it might be practical.

Most likely I would at least need to make larger diameter bags.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Got to check that out with a REV series and see if it might be practical.

Most likely I would at least need to make larger diameter bags.

My 1.5 and B series fit in their original bags no problem.. but I only have 6 kites in my Rev bag. Did think about rolling round a tube covered with foam so rods in the centre of tube then sail round tube (foam would help a little with the end caps etc) ... decided I needed to get a life!

Did speak to someone the other day who was thinking about a bigger tube with all his sails rolled round this and centre acting as storage for handles, lines etc ... all of which lives in a bigger tube/bag... would get pretty cumbersome...

You can see in my previous middle picture the 'packing' creases from how the sail arrived .. mylar films do fatigue if you keep using the same creases and thats really what I'm trying to avoid...

post-2056-1208079173_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Jonesey, I figured you might want to know on the power blast mostly out of the speed series there is a curl along the mylar panel under the leading edge that is also helped with the bungees on the ends, this helps give it it's float abilities and its encouraged to pack so that the ends maintain this curl on the ends.

The way your packing that will most defiantly remove that curl effecting its flight characteristics quickly.

However, for a regular Rev that does look like a great idea I just don't think I would do that with a speed series especially with a power blast 2-4 those are too expensive to ruin IMHO.

I believe in the video Joe makes note to this when packing it away.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Jonesey, I figured you might want to know on the power blast mostly out of the speed series there is a curl along the mylar panel under the leading edge that is also helped with the bungees on the ends, this helps give it it's float abilities and its encouraged to pack so that the ends maintain this curl on the ends.

The way your packing that will most defiantly remove that curl effecting its flight characteristics quickly.

However, for a regular Rev that does look like a great idea I just don't think I would do that with a speed series especially with a power blast 2-4 those are too expensive to ruin IMHO.

I believe in the video Joe makes note to this when packing it away.

Interesting point ... but I am not sure I agree.. the only way you can put shape into a mylar panel is by seaming, moulding (certain grand prix yacht sails are built over moulds) and tension so all the individual panels in a Rev are flat and the 'shape' is pulled in by the bungee tension and the way the sail interacts with the frame .... an easy way of showing this is to take a peice of paper out of your printer/photo copier and hold it by two diagonally opposite corners now pull them and site along the line between them.... you get a nice curve and the harder you pull the more the curve.. this is exactly what you see when the sail isnt loaded on the ground with tenison along the luff....

I think Ive got some old sailmaking software somwhere from another life that I must dig out and load up a rev sail to see what/where the load is going and what the flying shape is... would make for some ineresting discussions!

Anyway my knowledge of kites is minimal so I stand to be flamed but I have do have a lifetime of working with sails and would bet my life on the fact that any mylar material will last longer if its rolled then if its folded ... like you say the 2~4 is too expensive to ruin so thats why I'm going to roll mine!

By the way thanks for the advice on lines ... was nervous to try my 90# lines but used them yesterday and all was well... the more I fly the 2~4 the more I love it....still scares the s%&t out of me though!

Jonesey

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

The mesh on my original EXP failed about 3 months after I got it. A local kite shop replaced the mesh with a different sort (and added a couple of extra Dacron bits between the LE and the sail) and there was no further failure in the next year or so. My original 1.5 SUL also has the cracking mesh, plus other local fliers also have suffered this delight.

But on my home made sails (for all there other faults :-) ) the mesh has never failed, cracked, or done anything other than *be* some mesh. I don't take any special precautions with putting the Revolution away - almost from the beginning with the EXP I break down the leading edge, fold over into thirds, place the verticals against the LE (or in the case of the SLE spars: insert the verticals in inside the SLE spars) then roll from LE down to the TE.

I dont know if the mesh I (and the kite shop who did the original EXP repair) used is heavier or different from the standard Revolution type in some way - all I know is that a) it does the job and doesnt crack.

Perhaps it's true that some damage does result from "user abuse", but surely not all?

Jan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
The mesh on my original EXP failed about 3 months after I got it. A local kite shop replaced the mesh with a different sort (and added a couple of extra Dacron bits between the LE and the sail) and there was no further failure in the next year or so.

Jan

Jan was the Dacron put on where you fold the kite for storage? It is ashame that this is not solved because it does show up on a lot kites and it is frustrating. I really think it is a problem that can be solved. The Rev is a very rugged kite except for that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0
Jan was the Dacron put on where you fold the kite for storage? It is ashame that this is not solved because it does show up on a lot kites and it is frustrating. I really think it is a problem that can be solved. The Rev is a very rugged kite except for that.

No - the extra reinforcement was added like this: 1 piece in the center of the kite (where the bridle attachment goes), then 1 midway between the centre and the existing vertical dacron (both sides of course) and then 1 midway between the vertical dacron and the edge of the sail (again both sides) - 5 in total. I think you can just see what I mean on this this photo:

Picture of modified Rev EXP

None of these were where the folds would normally occur. The mesh used here is (as far as I can tell exactly) the same as mesh I have used on my homemade sails - and on those I only add the extra central piece of dacron on the leading edge. No problems with any mesh fabric so far (first one was made in February 2003, the vented version which as had alot of flying was made in May 2004) - still fine.

I agree it is frustrating as this is about the only fault (OK there are things that perhaps could/should be improved - thoese belong to another thread :-) ) with the build. Searching rec.kites I originally posted my question on 20th August 2001 - just sadens/annoys me that this is still seems to be an issue nearly 7 years later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

It makes the kite fly a bit smother, particularly in reverse, I believe. If I understand correctly it lets a little airflow through to the far side from the flier, restoring laminar flow on that side and thus making the kite more stable.

A vented v standard sail has a similar effect IMRO

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

If the mesh is breaking where the creases are from the standard '3 way' fold then its got to be something like a fatigue failure hasnt it? Hate to be repetative but I am going to continue to store all my kites rolled along the leading edge until someone can give me a reason not to!

And Jan when I sell you my spare shockwave it will come rolled!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...